Universities, especially in India and the U.S., are facing big challenges. These issues are not just about money, but also about freedom, politics, and what role universities should play in society.
🇺🇸 In the U.S.:
-
The Trump government (since Jan 2025) is putting pressure on universities like Harvard.
-
It froze $3.2 billion of Harvard’s grants and may remove its tax-free status.
-
Why? Because the government wants universities to change how they admit students, allow protests, hire faculty, and run programs like Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI).
-
Harvard is fighting back, saying this pressure is dangerous for education and freedom of thought.
🇮🇳 In India:
-
For over 40 years, universities have lost freedom. Decisions are now mostly taken by government bodies, not professors.
-
Professors are struggling with teaching and research, and their universities don’t always support them.
-
A famous private university didn’t stand up for its faculty recently — a sign of how weak university autonomy has become.
🎓 Why Autonomy (Freedom) Is Important:
-
Universities need independence to create new ideas and solve future problems (like fake news, AI, job changes).
-
Without freedom, professors can’t question old ways of thinking or propose better ones.
-
History shows that challenging old beliefs leads to big progress — like Galileo changing our view of the universe.
⚖️ The Big Tension:
-
Governments often want universities to support their own agenda and values.
-
But universities should also be anti-establishment — questioning power and helping society think in new ways.
-
This creates tension between what rulers want and what universities are meant to do.
💸 What About Funding?
-
Even rich private universities depend on government money because research is expensive.
-
In India, public funding has decreased since 1991, making universities weaker and more controlled by the state.
-
When funding comes with conditions, universities lose freedom.
-
Only a liberal government can offer money without control, supporting real academic freedom.
🧠 Why Universities Matter:
-
They don’t just teach — they create knowledge that shapes the future.
-
But today, short-term thinking, political pressure, and fake “knowledge” are harming real education.
-
Without freedom, universities become just a shell of what they were, and no one is left to defend them — which is what Harvard’s president warned about.
✅ Summary:
Universities must stay free and independent to help society progress. But in both India and the U.S., that freedom is under threat from governments trying to control them. Without autonomy, we risk losing creativity, truth, and meaningful progress.
